The Sacrifice Play — When "Fair Value" Is the Most Expensive Number for Minorities
Two take-privates closed within months of each other on opposite sides of the Sea of Japan. They used the same instrument. They produced opposite outcomes for the people who didn't sit at the table. In Korea, a private equity fund took the waste-management company Koentech private in mid-2025 at ₩9,000 per share. The fund assembled control through a tender offer, on-market purchases, and finally a comprehensive share swap. The tender offer fell short of plan — it secured about 20.2% — so the last resisting minority block, roughly 12.9% of the company, was forced out through the swap at that same ₩9,000. An independent valuation had called the price fair. Six months later, with no meaningful change in the business or its end-market, the fund moved to sell the company outright for a price in the mid-₩700 billion range — close to ₩15,000 per share, nearly double. Reporting estimated the squeezed-out minorities' stake carried roughly ₩40 billion of additional value they never rece...